Tuesday, March 10, 2009

Reconsider



Maybe I am moving a little off topic, but this post has been building in me over the last week and I just had to let it out. I previously wrote about the publishing industry's resistance to their changing marketplace- traditional newspapers and other publishing entities railing against lost advertising dollars and emerging troublesome internet journalism -but, I perhaps should have noted that they are far from alone in their fight. Traditionalists in the film, television and software industries are all struggling to come to terms with the horrifying openness of their new world.

And then there is music.

The big music labels and the RIAA were among the first to show their unwillingness to adapt when they started dropping lawsuits on twelve year olds in Wisconsin and old grannies for downloading a handful of mp3s. I don't intend to comment on their litigiousness, however. Rather, I am taking issue with their product launch model.

Grizzly Bear are a relatively 'big' band, by most standards: they opened for Radiohead on their last stadium tour and are capable of headlining large shows on their own, they make the standard talk-show television appearances on a regular basis, and each new album is met with a swarm of hype on and offline. They are a very good band with a substantial popular and critical following. Cool, right? They also have a new album due out on May 26th.

Want to hear it? No problem! Just google it. Veckatimest leaked two weeks ago.
... Three months before its drop date.

The current method of release is ridiculous. The band probably finished work on this album early in the year, handed it in to the label and were told to sit on their hands for awhile. The label then sent out a few copies out for review purposes and let one or two mp3s hit the Hype Machine, through bloggers or official downloads. Those lead singles sounded great and the fan got excited. Anticipation was high. The first reviews were glowing. Did the label honestly believe this album would stay under wraps until May?

This leak, like the other hundreds of leaks in the last five years, highlights the inadequacy of the music industry's business model. The Radiohead experiment proved that online downloads will not necessarily cannibalize later in-store sales, so long as the band has strong brand equity and the released product is high quality. So why not stagger the releases? Lead with online, hit the brick and mortar stores at the scheduled date. Even if the label is not comfortable with that idea, now that their consumers are downloading a poorly ripped, unofficial version of the album from torrents, why not provide them with a legitimate alternative? In my opinion, Veckatimest should have been up on iTunes, or the band's website or anywhere(!) as soon as the leak occured.

You can either rail against the internet, or you can learn how to make it work for your business. The music industry cannot expect its old models to work the way they did fifteen years ago.

Just as a bonus, here is Grizzle Bear performing 'Deep Blue Sea' during a show with the Brooklyn Philharmonic. Check it:

Monday, March 9, 2009

Obtrusion

The always enlightening BoingBoing.com ran a quick little piece on some recent advertising featured on Slate Magazine's homepage, and the annoyed response it drew from readers looking to just, you know, read the darn articles. Such people, would be greeted thusly:




Yikes.

The offending ads belong to VW, and though it appears they have either run their course or cannot be seen by incoming Canadian IP's, they raise an interesting question concerning taste and obrtusivness in online advertising: of course, you can make the ads as big and 'engaging' as you like, but is this really effective marketing?

Slate is a subsidiary of the Washington Post Company, and a quick check of a few of its sister-sites reveal a similar tale. Right now, they all sport animated Apple ads that cover the middle half of the browser window upon launch; forcing the viewer's eye to intake how green the new laptops are. So, well, you cannot read anything on the site without scrolling away.

This may seem like a small complaint, but I find it annoying when a site's immediate focal point is an ad. I appreciate the effort to get infront of the reader and win a little mindspace, but I didn't come to Slate to learn about how green the new Apple notebooks will be. How should a marketer balance the need to be seen, and the equally important need to not annoy the audience? There is a narrow border between acceptable presence (which does not necessarily mean peripheral) and overbearing obtrusion. The Washington Post Co. and its advertisers seem to have steered towards the latter in this case.

Tuesday, March 3, 2009

Look Down The Nose

I think most people would admit that we don't really know what to do with social networking, just yet. I mean, people have figured out how to use the devices personally, but using the business models behind them and their advertising potential is still in the learning stage. One ex-hacker seems recently suggested some fun ideas to stir up the conversation.

His name is Virgil Griffith, and he's a PhD student at Caltech. Griffith is really into data-mining on a a massive scale. He's devised a project where he compares the books listed as 'Favourites' on a user's Facebook page with the average SAT entrance score to the University they are currently attending (so, obviously, this is limited to the US). Based on which books score the most hits in schools with lower/higher standards he has created a graph entitled, Books That Make You Dumb.

Not a great endorsement for Alice Walker's The Color Purple or S.E. Hinton's The Oustiders. They are both pretty standard reading for middle school/early high school English classrooms, but I suppose if you're tastes stopped developing then...... well, its hard to prescribe much value to the graph. There are the issues of correlation does not mean causation and the fact that book taste may not indicate intelligence per se. But, of course, that is not the point. It is meant to be a conversation starter. This is Griffith's way of getting people to think about the different ways researchers/marketers/whoever can use the massive amounts of data being created by social networking users.

So what do you think? With Amazon releasing a terabyte of public data this week, where is data mining headed? And what are we going to be learning about ourselves?